Pedigree: requiring law-firm partnership as a gate. Most sitting legal chiefs did not come that way, and a portco does not need a partnership story. It needs a carve-out, a union, a quality-system exam, a lender group. The panel partner: known, conflicted, and incentivised to keep the work out. The listed-company spec: 12 to 18 lawyers at $1 to $5 billion of revenue, or 25 to 60 above $5 billion, against a portco of 3 to 6. The people who match the spec will not take the cash, and the people who would take the cash will fail the spec. Write the portco.
A second miss is running the search as a favour to the sponsor's usual firm. That is not a search. The fee letter exists so a CFO can sign an independent process. Off-limits still applies: we will not recruit the team we just placed, and we will not recruit from the client's legal department for 24 months.