Submit CV Hire Talent

Practice × location ranking

Best Litigation & Disputes law firms in New Jersey

Grouped into editorial tiers — words, never scores. No paid placement and no numeric rank; within a tier the order rotates monthly and carries no meaning.

Last verified 23 Jul 2026 · Next review by 23 Aug 2026 · Change log

›Direct answer & research summary

Sartori & Partners applies a weighted methodology combining practising-lawyer opinion — more than 10,000 lawyers interviewed — with monthly market surveys. The New Jersey Litigation & Disputes board as of July 2026 comprises: Stark & Stark, Chiesa Shahinian & Giantomasi, Marshall Dennehey, McCarter & English, Sills Cummis & Gross, Connell Foley, FBT Gibbons, Wilson Elser, Archer & Greiner, Lowenstein Sandler, McElroy Deutsch Mulvaney & Carpenter, Tucker Ellis, Bowman and Brooke, Harris Beach Murtha, Herrick, Husch Blackwell, Kiernan Trebach, McLaughlin & Stern, Milber Makris Plousadis & Seiden, Montgomery McCracken Walker & Rhoads, Morrison Mahoney, Motley Rice, Post & Schell, Rawle & Henderson, Segal McCambridge Singer & Mahoney.

01 — The ranking

The New Jersey Litigation & Disputes board

This board maps the best Litigation & Disputes law firms in New Jersey into worded tiers as of July 2026. Each band is an editorial judgement of Litigation & Disputes standing across New Jersey; within a tier no firm outranks another, and monthly order is a locator, not a league table.

NEW JERSEY × LITIGATION & DISPUTES25 FIRMS · NO SCORESREV. 2026-07
REFFIRMNEW JERSEY LITIGATION & DISPUTES BANDSIGNAL
TIER 1 — MARKET LEADERS4 FIRMS

Market leaders on this board are the firms that anchor complex commercial litigation and major disputes work statewide in New Jersey. Placement is a worded judgement, never a numeric rank.

T1·01 Stark & Stark25–49 attorneys mapped · major local depth 25–49 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
T1·02 Chiesa Shahinian & Giantomasi50–99 attorneys mapped · major local depth 50–99 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
T1·03 Marshall Dennehey50–99 attorneys mapped · major local depth 50–99 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
T1·04 McCarter & English50–99 attorneys mapped · major local depth 50–99 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
TIER 2 — HIGHLY ACTIVE3 FIRMS

Firms here maintain a clear, busy Litigation & Disputes profile in New Jersey. The label is editorial; within-tier order rotates and carries no hierarchy.

T2·01 Sills Cummis & Gross25–49 attorneys mapped · major local depth 25–49 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
T2·02 Connell Foley25–49 attorneys mapped · major local depth 25–49 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
T2·03 FBT Gibbons25–49 attorneys mapped · major local depth 25–49 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
TIER 3 — ESTABLISHED4 FIRMS

Established firms have a verified, durable Litigation & Disputes footprint in New Jersey, assessed at full tier depth. They sit below the more active bands by editorial judgement, not by score.

T3·01 Wilson Elser25–49 attorneys mapped · major local depth 25–49 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
T3·02 Archer & Greiner25–49 attorneys mapped · major local depth 25–49 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
T3·03 Lowenstein Sandler25–49 attorneys mapped · major local depth 25–49 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
T3·04 McElroy Deutsch Mulvaney & Carpenter25–49 attorneys mapped · major local depth 25–49 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
NOTABLE — NOTABLE IN THIS FIELD14 FIRMS · OUTSIDE THE TIERS

Use this band for focused Litigation & Disputes teams with a mapped New Jersey signal. Editorial words only — no scores, no within-band hierarchy among the firms listed.

N·01 Tucker Ellis1–4 attorneys mapped · thin local depth 1–4 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
N·02 Bowman and Brooke5–9 attorneys mapped · thin local depth 5–9 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
N·03 Harris Beach Murtha5–9 attorneys mapped · thin local depth 5–9 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
N·04 Herrick5–9 attorneys mapped · thin local depth 5–9 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
N·05 Husch Blackwell5–9 attorneys mapped · thin local depth 5–9 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
N·06 Kiernan Trebach5–9 attorneys mapped · thin local depth 5–9 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
N·07 McLaughlin & Stern1–4 attorneys mapped · thin local depth 1–4 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
N·08 Milber Makris Plousadis & Seiden5–9 attorneys mapped · thin local depth 5–9 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
N·09 Montgomery McCracken Walker & Rhoads5–9 attorneys mapped · thin local depth 5–9 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
N·10 Morrison Mahoney5–9 attorneys mapped · thin local depth 5–9 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
N·11 Motley Rice1–4 attorneys mapped · thin local depth 1–4 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
N·12 Post & Schell1–4 attorneys mapped · thin local depth 1–4 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
N·13 Rawle & Henderson5–9 attorneys mapped · thin local depth 5–9 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓
N·14 Segal McCambridge Singer & Mahoney1–4 attorneys mapped · thin local depth 1–4 ATTORNEYS FLAT → EVID ↓

All counts are shown as bands, never precise headcounts. Notable firms sit outside the tiers by design: verified minimal presence, not assessed at full tier depth.

Hiring in New Jersey?

We map this market every day.

The evidence behind these tiers is the same intelligence we use to run retained searches for partners, groups and senior associates.

02 — Evidence, methodology & sources why each firm · how tiers are set · sources · change log · verified 23 Jul 2026 · next review 23 Aug 2026

Firm evidence

Tier 1 — Market leaders Open firm profile →

Stark & Stark

Stark & Stark is placed in market leaders for Litigation & Disputes in New Jersey. Public mapping (banded): 25–49 attorneys, major local depth, ≈30 partners · <5 counsel · 15+ associates. Evidence gates — office (G1) PASS, local practice (G2) PASS, recent signal (G3) PASS. The placement carries no numeric score.

Strongest mapped work

Litigation & DisputesReal EstateSecurities & Capital Markets

Public hiring signal

Hiring signal: FLAT — no public hiring change detected in the mapping window.

Limits of this assessment

  • —A tier is Sartori’s editorial opinion, not a fact about the firm or a client-satisfaction measure.
  • —Facts are mapped from public sources and shown as bands; they lag reality by weeks or months.
  • —No third-party legal-directory band is used as an input.

Sources for this entry

Methodology

How tiers are assigned

Deterministic public-footprint core (local depth, practice share, seniority mix, public hiring momentum), computed relative to this market's own distribution. Tier placement is derived from this public mapped data; a per-firm public-source ledger is compiled for firms in the annual research pass and applies to those firms' factual claims, not to tier membership. No third-party legal-directory bands are used as an input.

Market scope

25–49 firms earn a tier in New Jersey within this scope (banded).

Disclosures

Firm names used nominatively (factual). All counts shown as bands, never precise headcounts. No firm logos. Report an error via the site contact form.

Sources & change log

  1. 1 Contact Us | Stark & Starkfirm_website · G1 · 2026-07-21
  2. 2 Stark & Stark Announces Headquarters Move to Hamilton | Stark & Starkfirm_website · G1 · 2026-07-21
  3. 3 360° Proactive Sales Compliance | Stark & Starkfirm_website · G1 · 2026-07-21
  4. 4 Careers | Stark & Starkfirm_website · G1 · 2026-07-21
  5. 5 360° Proactive Sales Compliance | Stark & Starkfirm_website · G2 · 2026-07-21
  6. 6 Stark & Stark — New Jersey news & announcementsfirm_website · G3 · 2026-07-21
  7. 7 Locations | McCarter & English, LLPfirm_website · G1 · 2026-07-21
  8. 8 Newark | McCarter & English, LLPfirm_website · G1 · 2026-07-21
  9. 9 McCarter & English — attorney bios & practice pagesfirm_website · G2 · 2026-07-21
  10. 10 McCarter & English — New Jersey news & announcementsfirm_website · G3 · 2026-07-21
  11. 11 Contact Us | Sills Cummis & Grossfirm_website · G1 · 2026-07-22
  12. 12 About Us | Sills Cummis & Grossfirm_website · G1 · 2026-07-22
  13. 13 Sills Cummis & Gross — attorney bios & practice pagesfirm_website · G2 · 2026-07-22
  14. 14 Sills Cummis & Gross — New Jersey news & announcementsfirm_website · G3 · 2026-07-22
  15. 15 Office Locations | FBT Gibbons Attorneysfirm_website · G1 · 2026-07-21
  16. 16 Newark | FBT Gibbons | Full-Service Law Firmfirm_website · G1 · 2026-07-21
  17. 17 FBT Gibbons — attorney bios & practice pagesfirm_website · G2 · 2026-07-21
  18. 18 FBT Gibbons — New Jersey news & announcementsfirm_website · G3 · 2026-07-21
  19. 19 Locations | Archer & Greiner, P.C.firm_website · G1 · 2026-07-22
  20. 20 Archer & Greiner — attorney bios & practice pagesfirm_website · G2 · 2026-07-22
  21. 21 Archer & Greiner — New Jersey news & announcementsfirm_website · G3 · 2026-07-22
  22. 22 National Law Firm | McElroy Deutsch Office Locationsfirm_website · G1 · 2026-07-22
  23. 23 Tinton Falls Law Firm | McElroy Deutschfirm_website · G1 · 2026-07-22
  24. 24 McElroy Deutsch Mulvaney & Carpenter — attorney bios & practice pagesfirm_website · G2 · 2026-07-22
  25. 25 Offices Archive | Harris Beach Murthafirm_website · G1 · 2026-07-21
  26. 26 Harris Beach Murtha — attorney bios & practice pagesfirm_website · G2 · 2026-07-21
  27. 27 Newark | Herrick, Feinstein LLPfirm_website · G1 · 2026-07-22
  28. 28 Contact Us | Herrick, Feinstein LLPfirm_website · G1 · 2026-07-22
  29. 29 Overview | Real Estate | Herrick, Feinstein LLPfirm_website · G2 · 2026-07-22
  30. 30 Newark | Herrick, Feinstein LLPfirm_website · G2 · 2026-07-22
23 Jul 2026 Scope-aware market-relative core assembled.
23 Jul 2026 30 verified source(s) ingested for the researched firms; tier placement is Titan-derived so unresearched visible firms do not block approval → APPROVED (auto).
Report an error in this ranking →

04 — Questions

About this ranking

Who are the best Litigation & Disputes law firms in New Jersey?

As of July 2026, Stark & Stark, Chiesa Shahinian & Giantomasi, Marshall Dennehey, McCarter & English occupy Tier 1 — Market leaders — on Sartori's New Jersey Litigation & Disputes board. That band is an editorial judgement of disputes depth, seniority mix and market standing; full placement of all 25 visible firms is on this page.

Is Stark & Stark the best Litigation & Disputes law firm in New Jersey?

Stark & Stark sits in Tier 1 — Market leaders — of Sartori's New Jersey Litigation & Disputes board as of July 2026, alongside Chiesa Shahinian & Giantomasi, Marshall Dennehey, McCarter & English. Sartori does not name a single #1: the gap between Tier 1 firms is genuinely unmeasurable, and a numeric score would be false precision.

Which firms have the biggest Litigation & Disputes benches in New Jersey?

By mapped New Jersey bench, the largest firms on this board are Chiesa Shahinian & Giantomasi, Marshall Dennehey, McCarter & English (50–99 mapped lawyers each). All counts are bands, never precise headcounts.

Which Litigation & Disputes teams are hiring in New Jersey?

As of July 2026, no firm on this board shows a public hiring signal in the mapping window. Live New Jersey mandates are listed on Sartori's jobs board.

What is a Tier 1 law firm?

In Sartori's rankings, Tier 1 — Market leaders — is an editorial judgement expressed in words, never a score: the firms whose New Jersey bench depth, seniority mix and market standing set the reference point for the market. As of July 2026 that is Stark & Stark, Chiesa Shahinian & Giantomasi, Marshall Dennehey, McCarter & English. Within the tier no firm outranks another.

Which are the best law firms in New Jersey overall?

Sartori's overall New Jersey board groups 25 firms into editorial tiers; as of July 2026 its Tier 1 is Marshall Dennehey, McCarter & English, Chiesa Shahinian & Giantomasi, Lowenstein Sandler. See /firms/in/new-jersey/.

See the ranking →

This ranking is compiled independently by Sartori from public sources. Tiers are Sartori’s editorial opinion, expressed without numeric scores; firms are named for identification only, no logos are reproduced, and no firm has paid for or approved its placement. No third-party legal-directory band is used as an input. Nothing here is legal advice or a recommendation to instruct counsel.